• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Untold Recipes By Nosheen
  • All Recipes
  • My Story
  • Subscribe
  • Work With Me
  • Summer
menu icon
go to homepage
  • All Recipes
  • My Story
  • Subscribe
  • Work With Me
  • Summer
search icon
Homepage link
  • All Recipes
  • My Story
  • Subscribe
  • Work With Me
  • Summer
×
Untold Recipes by Nosheen » Recipes » Pakistani Recipes

Nihari (Pakistani Beef Shank Stew)

Modified: Feb 23, 2025 · Published: Sep 16, 2020 by Nosheen Babar · This post may contain affiliate links · 22 Comments

Sharing is caring!

212 shares
  • Facebook118
  • LinkedIn
  • Print
  • Email
Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Nihari (Pakistani Beef Shank Stew) is a delicious and ancient one-pot recipe. After 15 minutes of prep, the shank stew is slow-cooked for 4 hours. The result is a delightful and aromatic stew with meat that melts in your mouth.

Nihari topped with ginger, chopped green chilies and cilantro microgreens.

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?

We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!

This slow-cooked Pakistani stew made with beef shank dates back to the late 17th or Early 18th Century. The word Nihari comes from the Arabic word Nihar which means morning. The name is apt as the shank stew was served to the Nawabs during the early morning prayer.

This Pakistani beef shank stew recipe continues to be a popular choice for breakfast and brunch today. A popular street food, Nihari is a special weekend breakfast treat like sooji halwa, aloo masala, and chana masala.

Jump to:
  • Why you'll love this recipe
  • The ingredients
  • Substitutions & variations
  • Step-by-step instructions
  • Expert tips
  • Recipe FAQS
  • Other recipes you may like
  • Nihari Recipe (Pakistani Beef Shank Stew)

Why you'll love this recipe

  • The perfect recipe to feed a crowd - This hearty Pakistani beef shank stew is a stand-alone recipe that's always a crowd-pleaser. No complicated menus to plan for your guests and no extra time to double or even triple this recipe.
  • Delicious leftovers - Nihari freezes well and tastes better when reheated. Who doesn't like amazing leftovers?
  • Authentic Street Food Taste - This recipe's homemade blend of spices delivers a Nihari just like the one you would enjoy on the streets of Karachi.
  • No added preservatives - The Nihari will be completely organic since you'll be making your own spice blend from scratch.

The ingredients

The two things essential to an amazing pot of Nihari are the meat and the spice blend.

White countertop with bowls that contain shank meat, oil, flour, garlic paste and onions.

The meat

  • The Meat - Bone in Shank Meat cut into big pieces is what is traditionally used in this recipe. The bones and marrow are essential to the stew.
  • The Flour - A special wholemeal wheat flour known as Durum flour or Atta is used to thicken the Nihari. It is easily available on Amazon.
  • The Onions - I always use yellow onions for their neutral taste. In this recipe, I fry them and add them to the Nihari as a tadka, or tempering, at the end.

The spice blend

All the spices needed to cook Nihari in small bowls with labels on a white countertop.
  • Long Pepper - Long pepper, also known as Piper Longum and Pippali is a relative of black pepper. It has a more complex taste and is almost like an entire spice blend in one tiny little capsule. Earthy, smoky, and floral, Pippali is an essential ingredient in the Nihari spice blend. It is available in all South Asian stores, on Amazon, and at specialty spice stores such as Curio Spice Co.
  • Black Cumin - Black cumin seeds are thinner and smaller than traditional brown cumin seeds and taste like caraway seeds. They are used in many savory Pakistan and Indian recipes, adding a delicious aroma to recipes like Chicken Pulao.
  • Black Cardamom - Black cardamom has a warm smoky taste and aroma, quite unlike the floral notes in green cardamom. Very strong on its own when used to make spice blends, such as Chicken Korma or Mutton Biryani the result is perfect.

Grinding your own spices in small batches to make your own Homemade Nihari Masala by far leads to a more flavorful dish. A bold homemade spice blend is what gives this Pakistani beef shank stew an authentic Old Delhi taste.

Any leftover spices can be reused to make spice blends for other recipes, such as Beef Pasanday and Pakistani Beef Haleem Recipe.

The garnishes

White countertop with green chilies, lemons, cilantro and crushed garlic.
  • Green Chilies - I use serrano peppers since I like things spicy! If you want to tame things down, deseed the peppers.
  • Ginger - I usually julienne the ginger, but if I'm serving a large crowd, I simply peel it and run it through my food processor.

For the complete list of ingredients with measurements plus recipe instructions, please see the recipe card at the bottom of this post.

Substitutions & variations

  • Try different meat - If you have trouble sourcing bone-in beef shank, just use tender boneless beef such as chuck(front shoulder) or round(rear muscle) and buy some marrow bones separately to add to the shank stew.
  • Use a store-bought spice blend - If you want to save some time then I recommend using Nihari Masala by shanfoods.com or nfoodstore.com for your Nihari.
  • Make the stew gluten-free - To make the Nihari gluten-free, use brown rice flour instead of Atta (Durum whole wheat flour).
  • Pair the stew with crusty warm French bread - Switch things up and try some warm crusty French bread with your Pakistani beef shank stew instead of Naan.
  • Make delicious sandwiches with leftover meat - The leftover melt-in-your-mouth Nihari meat tastes amazing in sandwiches.

Step-by-step instructions

Step 1 - Heat the cooking oil, sauté the garlic paste for about 30 seconds, and then add the meat to it.

Step 2 - Cook the meat and sauté it till it just changes color and is no longer pink.

Step 3 - add in the prepared spice blend and stir fry for a few minutes to allow the spices to bloom or temper.

Step 4 - Add in enough water to just cover the meat and bones, and bring the mixture to a boil.

Step 5 - Then reduce the flame to low medium heat and cook the Nihari for around 3-4 hours.

Step 6 - Once the meat is tender, I remove it using a slotted spoon. I wait for it to cool a little bit and then remove any excess fat and discard it along with the bones, adding the marrow back to my curry.

Step 7 - Make a smooth flour paste using 1 cup of atta and 2 cups of hot water. Add this slurry in slowly and stir constantly till the Nihari thickens. This will prevent lumps from forming.  

Step 8 - Thinly slice a medium onion and fry it in some oil till it's crispy and dark brown. Then pour the fried onions along with the oil over your Nihari.

Expert tips

  • Remove the fat on the meat after it's cooked - I find that leaving the fat on the meat adds a lot of flavor to the shank stew. Plus, after 4 hours of cooking, it peels right off, making the whole process more efficient.
  • Make sure to add the marrow - Remove the bones from the mixture and discard them, but do add the marrow back to the stew as it really adds loads of flavor.
  • Always use hot water to make the slurry - This way there is no rapid change in temperature as you add the slurry, resulting in a smooth mixture without any clumps.
  • Keep some hot boiled water on hand - If the Nihari seems to be getting too thick too fast, add a cup of hot water to help thin it out.
  • Add some tempered Kashmiri chilies to your stew - As you fry the onions, add just 1 tablespoon of Kashmiri red chili powder to the oil at the end. This will give your Pakistani beef shank stew a restaurant finish.

Recipe FAQS

How should I store my Nihari?

Nihari is the perfect food to prepare in bulk and store as it always tastes better when reheated! In the fridge, it will stay okay in an airtight container for up to 3-5 days. In the freezer, it will last for up to 3 months!

I don't have Atta, what can I substitute with?

prepare a flour slurry using Atta, whole wheat flour made of Durum Wheat. You can substitute with Whole wheat flour if you don't have Atta. But this will alter the taste and texture of the Nihari.

Why do we add the onions at the end and not at the beginning?

The caramelized onions added at the end retain their full flavor, aroma, and color and the result is a richer stew.

What is Nalli Nihari?

Nalli refers to the bones that contain the marrow and gives the meat stew its amazing flavor. Nalli Nihari usually indicates that the Nihari was cooked with bone in shanks and that the stew contains marrow.

Nihari topped with ginger, chopped green chilies and cilantro microgreens.

Other recipes you may like

  • Cooked bihari kabab are plated and garnished with green chilies, sliced white onions and lemon slices.
    Bihari Kabab
  • Tandoori grilled lambchops in a tray lined with parchment paper, served with grilled corn, roasted baby egg plants, pickled red thai chilies and fresh lemon.
    Tandoori Grilled Lamb Chops Recipe
  • roast leg of goat {raan}
    Roast Leg Of Goat (Raan)
  • A pakistani chicken pulao ,plated in a beige platter, with a golden spoon and fork on the side, is resting on an orange napkin.
    Chicken Pulao (Pakistani Recipe)

For more Pakistani recipes like this, check out 20 popular Pakistani recipes. If you decide to try this recipe, Please don't forget to leave a rating and comment below! If you take a picture then tag me on Instagram! Thank You!

Nihari topped with ginger, chopped green chilies and cilantro microgreens.

Nihari Recipe (Pakistani Beef Shank Stew)

Nosheen Babar
This Nihari (Pakistani Beef Shank Stew) is a traditional slow-cooked one-pot meal made with a beef shank in a rich, spicy gravy.
5 from 31 votes
Pin Recipe Print Recipe Save Saved!

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?

We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!

Prep Time 15 minutes mins
Cook Time 4 hours hrs
slurry and tadka 30 minutes mins
Total Time 4 hours hrs 45 minutes mins
Course Breakfast, Main Course
Cuisine Indian, Pakistani
Servings 10 people
Calories 459 kcal

Ingredients
  

Nihari Masala Mix (For 5 pounds of meat)

  • 10 whole green cardamom 
  • 2 whole black cardamom
  • 3 whole cinnamon sticks
  • 2 whole star anise
  • 10 whole cloves
  • 3 tablespoon coriander seeds
  • 1 tablespoon cumin seeds
  • 3 tablespoon fennel seeds
  • 1 teaspoon black peppercorns
  • ½ piece nutmeg
  • 1 piece mace
  • 4 whole long black pepper (Piper Longum) (see notes)
  • ½ teaspoon black cumin seeds
  • 6 whole bay leaves
  • 4 whole red dried chilies
  • 1 teaspoon ginger powder
  • 3 teaspoon salt
  • 4 teaspoon red chili powder
  • 2 teaspoon turmeric powder
  • 2 teaspoon kashmiri chili powder

The Ingredients

  • 5 lb beef shank (see notes)
  • 1 cup cooking oil
  • 5 tablespoon garlic paste
  • 12 cups water
  • 1 cup whole wheat flour (see notes)
  • 2 whole onions

The Garnish

  • 2 whole lemons
  • ½ cup cilantro
  • 2 whole green chillies (see notes)
  • 2 inch ginger piece

Instructions
 

Nihari Masala Mix (For 5 pounds of meat)

  • Dry roast all of the whole spices in a nonstick frying pan for 2-5 minutes. Constantly stir to prevent burning and remove them from the pan as soon as they release their aroma.
  • Grind all of these spices to a fine powder and then mix them with the powder spices (see notes).

Nihari

  • Heat ½ cup cooking oil in your pot.
  • Add and saute the garlic for 2-3 minutes.
  • Add the meat and the nalli (marrow bones) and roast till they are no longer red.
  • Add the ground spices and 10 cups of water and bring the mixture to a boil
  • Lower heat to medium and simmer for 4 hours.
  • Prepare a slurry with the remaining 2 cups of water and durum flour and add to the Nihari, constantly stirring to prevent any clumps forming. Cover and simmer for another 15 minutes (see notes)
  • Thinly slice and fry the onions in a ¼ cup of oil to a dark brown. Pour the onions and oil on the Nihari and simmer for another 15 minutes.

Garnish

  • Quarter the lemons.
  • Finely chop the cilantro.
  • Thinly slice the ginger.
  • Finely chop the green chilies.

Notes

  • Long Pepper -  Also known as Piper Longum and Pippali, is an Indian Long Pepper that is the primary ingredient in Nihari. You just won't get that authentic taste without it in the mix so I highly recommend sourcing it from Amazon and using it.
  • Beef Shank - The best meat to use for the Nihari is bone-in Beef Shank. Make sure to buy and use marrow bones as well. This is what really gives the stew its rich flavor and a special trip to the butcher will be well worth your effort.
  • The flour - Use Durum wheat flour, known as "Atta" for this recipe. This is wholemeal wheat flour and has a distinctly nutty taste. The recipe will be better with this, but if you can't source it then use regular wheat flour.
  • Serrano Chilies - The closest to the Pakistani chilies I grew up eating, these are my go-to when cooking all of my curries. I find that other chili varieties just don't give that authenticity of flavor to my food. If you find them too spicy, you can deseed them.
  • Spice grinder - I use a coffee grinder as my spice grinder and find that it grinds all my spices quickly and efficiently. 
  • Preparing the slurry - Make sure to prepare the flour slurry with hot water to prevent the flour from clumping. 

Nutrition

Serving: 1personCalories: 459kcalCarbohydrates: 18gProtein: 33gFat: 29gSaturated Fat: 4gPolyunsaturated Fat: 7gMonounsaturated Fat: 17gTrans Fat: 0.1gCholesterol: 53mgSodium: 827mgPotassium: 760mgFiber: 5gSugar: 1gVitamin A: 575IUVitamin C: 4mgCalcium: 123mgIron: 6mg
Have you tried this recipe yet?Mention @Untoldrecipesbynosheen or tag #Untoldrecipesbynosheen!

More Pakistani Recipes

  • Four-ingredient mango dessert.
    Mango Mousse (Only 4-Ingredients!)
  • Beef boti kebab rice platter.
    Beef Boti Kebab Rice Platter
  • Chicken shawarma served with rice, vegetables and a creamy sauce.
    Chicken Shawarma Bowl
  • Homemade no churn ice cream in a bowl.
    Caramel Crunch Ice Cream Recipe

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Samra011

    August 12, 2024 at 4:07 am

    I made this recipe yesterday and followed it closely, but I couldn’t find piper longum anywhere, not even at Patel Brothers. I ended up using more pepper, nutmeg, and ginger instead. The spice level wasn’t quite the same, but it still turned out delicious! If you’re interested in trying some authentic nihari without the effort of making it yourself, you can order it online here: https://soughat.pk/product/javed-nihari/.

    Reply
    • Nosheen Babar

      August 13, 2024 at 8:26 pm

      Hi Samra!
      Thank you for trying my recipe. The piper longum is often an issue, but I've provided some links in the recipe post and you can order it online if you decide to make the recipe again. Thank you for the Javed Nihari suggestion, will try it soon.
      Nosheen

      Reply
  2. Misha

    June 14, 2024 at 9:51 am

    Hi Nosheen, I hope you are well. I am looking to make this recipe for Eid on sunday and wanted to confirm the size of the cinnamon sticks you are using. thank you

    Reply
    • Nosheen Babar

      June 14, 2024 at 10:16 am

      Hi Misha,
      So glad you’re trying this recipe. Use 1 inch cinnamon sticks.

      Reply
      • Misha

        June 14, 2024 at 1:46 pm

        Thank you very much! Will let you know how it goes!

      • Nosheen Babar

        June 14, 2024 at 3:46 pm

        Can't wait for a review.

      • Misha

        June 16, 2024 at 3:20 am

        It turned out amazing! Thank you for the recipe, the proportions used were perfect ?

      • Nosheen Babar

        June 16, 2024 at 10:18 pm

        Hi Misha. Thank you for trying the recipe and sharing your feedback.

  3. Behnam

    August 06, 2023 at 4:57 am

    I would like to put a comment on the word Nihar. Concidering my travels and living in Oman and Iran, I think the word Nihar means day time and was used for Lunch. In Persian "Nahar" is still used for "Lunch".
    But anyhow your recipes make my family mad 🙂
    Thank you

    Reply
    • Nosheen Babar

      August 06, 2023 at 10:11 am

      Thank You for the clarification. I will recheck the meaning per my sources.I’m glad you’re enjoying the recipes -:)

      Reply
  4. Behnam

    August 06, 2023 at 4:48 am

    Hi and thank you so much for all the resipe info besides the way to cook.
    I am not Pakistani but have lived in North Pakistan at the time it used to be NWFP. I have seen some of your dishes and they are amazing and further more than it used to be when I was there.
    Your resipes bring me back memories.

    Reply
    • Nosheen Babar

      August 06, 2023 at 10:09 am

      Thank You Behnam,
      I’m glad you’re enjoying the recipes-:)

      Reply
  5. Saima

    April 01, 2023 at 11:27 pm

    5 stars
    This recipe is AMAZING! I didn’t have piper longum, but it turned out delicious! Will definitely be making this again ?

    Reply
    • Nosheen Babar

      April 01, 2023 at 11:34 pm

      So glad you tried it and liked it Saima. Do try and add the piper longum next time.It makes a lot of difference to the taste!

      Reply
  6. Ofri

    March 28, 2023 at 4:51 pm

    5 stars
    Great recipe everyone enjoyed it

    Reply
    • Nosheen Babar

      March 28, 2023 at 4:57 pm

      Thank You so much!

      Reply
  7. n/a

    December 04, 2022 at 12:58 am

    5 stars
    I am not Pakistani but my fiance is. I decided to make this dish because I myself grew up eating it at friends' homes and wanted to do something special for him. I followed the recipe and was only missing 2-3 spices in the list. Nonetheless the Nihari turned out so good and delicious. Hopefully next time I will have the piper longum and star anise in my pantry 🙂 Thank you for your recipes <3

    Reply
    • untoldrecipesbynosheen

      December 04, 2022 at 8:54 am

      Thank You for trying the recipe! I’m so glad it turned out well and that you plan to make it again!Appreciate your feedback!

      Reply
  8. Sanjay

    June 19, 2022 at 8:43 am

    5 stars
    Hi there! This is an excellent recipe! One quick question, I assume the 5lbs of meat includes the bones - right?

    Cheers!

    Reply
    • untoldrecipesbynosheen

      June 19, 2022 at 11:10 am

      Thank You and yes it does include the bones! Hope you like the final product! Please do rate the recipe once you make it!

      Reply
  9. Sajid

    May 16, 2021 at 11:19 am

    Hi
    I made this yesterday and followed your recipe to a T...except for the piper longum. I know, I know! Honestly, I looked all over for some, including Patel Brothers who are the mother of ALL Indian grocers and even they didn't have any. I google researched it and added extra pepper, nutmeg and ginger. It wasn't as spicy as I remember, and maybe that's why. But I thoroughly enjoyed it!

    Reply
    • untoldrecipesbynosheen

      May 17, 2021 at 10:27 pm

      Hi Sajid,
      So glad you tried the recipe. I guess I should have mentioned in the post that I got the piper longum from Amazon. It does make a huge difference to the taste of the Nihari. Maybe next time you can order it. As far as the spices are concerned, I usually keep the spice and salt levels at a medium in the recipe to suit the needs of a larger audience and you can perhaps add a bit more red chilli powder to the recipe or top your bowl with chopped thai chilies which are really hot and will spice it up nicely. As always I really value your honest feedback and appreciate you trying my recipes.

      Reply
5 from 31 votes (27 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Primary Sidebar

Nosheen headshot

Welcome to Untold Recipes by Nosheen!

Here, you'll find authentic Pakistani recipes inspired by my childhood—a curated space to explore nostalgic recipes for all aspiring home cooks. It's all here, from slow-cooked Mughal wonders to regional delicacies and street food favorites. I aim to make all the recipes approachable for beginner, intermediate, and advanced cooks alike.

More about me

Spring Recipes

  • Pakistani style zucchini curry with naan.
    Pakistani Zucchini (Courgette) Curry
  • Chicken malai tikka skewers accompanied with red onions and lemon wedges are resting in a platter lined with brown paper.
    Chicken Malai Tikka
  • An air fryer asparagus recipe is plated in a blue plate that is resting on a greay napkin with gold cutlery.
    Air Fryer Asparagus Recipe
  • Thai chicken salad with mango is being served in a neutral colored bowl.
    Thai Chicken Salad With Mango
  • Raw mango chutney is plated in a bowl resting on a silver tray on top of a dark gray napkin.
    Raw Mango Chutney Recipe (No-Cook)
  • Sweet and spicy watermelon snack in abowl.
    Watermelon Chaat Recipe

Popular Recipes

  • Nihari topped with ginger, chopped green chilies and cilantro microgreens.
    Nihari (Pakistani Beef Shank Stew)
  • Mutton birayni is plated in a dark metal tray and served with raita and kachumber.
    Mutton Biryani Recipe
  • roast leg of goat {raan}
    Roast Leg Of Goat (Raan)
  • Cooked bihari kabab are plated and garnished with green chilies, sliced white onions and lemon slices.
    Bihari Kabab
  • Beef karahi gosht recipe.
    Beef Karahi Gosht Recipe
  • Brown parchment with cooked chicken tikka boti on skewers with green chutney, onions and micro greens.
    Easy Chicken Tikka Boti Recipe

Footer

as seen in:

allrecipes logo

Privacy Policy & Disclaimer
Accessibility Policy

Back To Top

Copyright © 2025 Untold Recipes By Nosheen

Rate This Recipe

Your vote:




A rating is required
A name is required
An email is required

Recipe Ratings without Comment

Something went wrong. Please try again.